First, kudos to Rebornica for actually thinking of this theory, I’m only developing it a bit further, anyway, on with the theory/fact.
But the “New” Animatronics were taken away!
I know! But let’s think about this, from night 4 to night 5, the flashback with the puppet in front of the Freddy animatronic. Was there a way for the Puppet stick with FazBear Ent.?
Well… In the game it looks like the Puppet can exit the box at will when its song has fully played, with the police running around it could have possibly left the box and hid somewhere else, while his box was taken away. But wouldn’t that mean that the Puppet would freely walk through the halls in FNAF1? Not exactly… Remember the audio queues? The pots and pans in the kitchen? The Freddy music? Foxy’s humming? The Circus/Carnival music with no source? Why would the animatronics do such a thing? Chica’s usually fast and stealthy and yet in the kitchen she plays with the pots and pans, Freddy is the most menacing animatronic and makes no sounds whatsoever, unless you consider his laugh, so why sing his song in the kitchen? And Foxy…why would you hum something when you’re behind the curtain and nobody knows about you at first? And that Circus/Carnival music? Where does it come from?
Let’s think about this for a bit more, we never see the Puppet right? And there’s no way we missed it if he walked around, right? Wrong, one camera does not work, one camera which makes people think that Golden Freddy hides from everything. The Kitchen…
The Puppet is stopped by sound right? Remember how you got to keep the box constantly winded or else the Puppet would hunt you down? Well think about this, what if the animatronics are trying to protect you? Or protect themselves from the Puppet?
I say protect you cause the animatronics aren’t supposed to be evil, and it’s the spirits of the children that are driving them to kill people, so we might assume there’s a bit of an inner fight happening. But the latter choice seems more legitimate, would you not be afraid of the thing that stuffed your body/soul into an animatronic? I know I sure would! And let’s not forget Golden Freddy, people normally assume he hides in the kitchen. What if, Golden Freddy is actually guarding the Puppet by playing the Circus/Carnival music from time to time? We already know he wasn’t the culprit for the children’s murder, and that the Puppet attacked him, or did something to him, in FNAF2 so it wouldn’t be too farfetched to state that Golden Freddy is trying to stop the Puppet, alongside the other animatronics/kids.
YES. Exactly
ALSO, remember in the cutscenes where you are looking through Freddy’s eyes in FNAF2 that Golden Freddy is staring right at you and then in the later cutscene…instead of Golden Freddy..it’s the puppet.
