I'd think the whole thing would be tainted by the evil in the vampire. I mean, basic rule of physics: Everything seeks equilibrium. What's left of the vampire would slowly disperse throughout the holy water, removing the holiness of it thanks to the evil within said vampire. And yeah, even a small bit should ruin the entire batch. Holy likes "purity" and even the smallest bit of evil makes the water "impure"

Yeah, the person I consulted said it would be “diluted to worthlessness”

  1. silver-tongues-blog posted this