A:is the most attractive.

Most attractive would be either lapis or azure. One of the paints.

D:fears death the most.

The one who fears death the most would be Pygmalion. They’re trying to work towards immortality.

J:tells the most dad jokes

Azure is the only OC I have who is a father so I guess it would be him.

O:has the most OCs of their own.

Agate if you count her experiments or pyg if you count their aliases.

S:has the strongest spirit.

Topaz. Definitely Topaz. His duty is towards the betterment of the queen and the deer citizens.

W:watches the most anime.

Topaz and agate would be total weebs if anime existed. Maybe Pygmalion too.

Z:gets the most overzealous over something others wouldn’t expect.Most 

Lapis when she finds someone she actually likes.