One of the things that I love about Elementary is the way they demystify Sherlock’s deduction process. It’s like, most other Sherlock adaptations treat his detective skills as a purely inborn quality: a natural, inexplicable talent that’s completely unobtainable by anyone else.
But Elementary goes “you know what? I bet Sherlock put a lot of work into developing and honing those skills, and that he could teach those skills to other people”. Sure, there’s definitely a measure of natural talent to it, but it’s also made clear that it’s just as much about training and learning and depending on others when your own knowledge and skills aren’t enough.
In the process, it’s also tacitly acknowledged that Sherlock couldn’t be what he is or do the things he does if he hadn’t been born so privileged. The only reason why he’s had the time and opportunity to train himself up, to gather such a deep and varied well of knowledge and to form such a vast network of experts he can contact for help, is because he’s rich.
Without his father’s money, he would have less time to devote to bettering himself as a detective: he would have to worry about earning a paycheck, about keeping himself fed and housed and keeping his living space clean and orderly without the help of a housekeeper.
He would have to worry about the cost of his experiments and equipment and consulting fees and all sorts of other mundane things that would clutter up his mind. He would have to charge for his services, and accept boring cases just to pay the bills.
Without his father’s money, he wouldn’t have his extensive education. He wouldn’t have the Brownstone. He wouldn’t have Watson.
And I think part of the reason why Sherlock doesn’t accept payment for his work is because he’s well aware of the advantages he’s been afforded in life, well aware that his clients don’t always share in those advantages, and compassionate enough to acknowledge it as unjust.
lifeisinthepixels liked this
fuchszie liked this ly--canthrope reblogged this from radiophile
hiccup-is-left-handed liked this
muthserra reblogged this from hunterinabrowncoat
muthserra liked this
fullhideoutdragon liked this
kitlandslot reblogged this from thepinkrvnger
kitlandslot liked this
kino-verite reblogged this from kino-verite cirth-ithil liked this
therobinair liked this
that-crow-is-a-raven reblogged this from lemonyandbeatrice
that-crow-is-a-raven liked this
caretta-caretta liked this
tatsunoko-pioneer liked this
bubblegum-discoqueen reblogged this from bubblegum-discoqueen autisticassassinbird reblogged this from leafenclaw
gildedsentinel reblogged this from cowpants147
gildedsentinel liked this
vvitchllng liked this
icannotweave reblogged this from disablednicodiangelo
fluffygreyninjacat liked this
blue-ink-pearls reblogged this from lacommunarde
jackthesnacc reblogged this from scottmcstark kafkovski liked this
raeofalbion liked this
leafenclaw reblogged this from liitohauki thetimetravellercat reblogged this from themushroomblues
thetimetravellercat liked this
the-bookwyrm liked this parvusmundus liked this
just-ambling-along reblogged this from spirantization
bookwummy liked this
silentspaces reblogged this from thirdstrings thelaxoddish liked this
shatteringrevelations liked this yami-kada reblogged this from rhaedarofworlds
rhaedarofworlds reblogged this from littlebluewing
violethairedsappho reblogged this from swingsetindecember
blackrabbitofoverwatch liked this
wolfabwip liked this
lost-love-ligeia liked this hurricane-in-a-teacup reblogged this from jhaernyl
life-death-thepursuitofhappiness liked this horton-hears-a-doctor-who liked this
cakesword reblogged this from liitohauki
liitohauki posted this
- Show more notes