(My DM had set up a situation where he would attack us all with a spell that deafened us and made us drop our weapons. The plan was, when we were retrieving them, he would attack us with multiple surprise attacks. Before he could put this into action…)

DM: “Wait, are any of you Chaotic?”

Party: *Seven out of nine of us raise our hands.*

DM: *single, silent beat.* Well…Damn it.