jayrockin:

Very nice venation! Only issue is the lack of discernible petioles. The leaves seem to join the stem as they would on a molded plastic toy. 9/10

I’m bitter about this design almost entirely because when I search for enamel pins of shamrocks, they all look exactly like this with no variation. Only saving grace is instant iconographic readability. 4/10

Props for having a distinctive art style, but honestly this looks more like something an elephant would wear to a masquerade ball than a group of leaves. 5/10

It’s a little bit jelly-candy-esque, but I’m digging the shading. Similar to the Apple emoji, the main flaw is the lack of petioles, though the leaves are also arranged rather sloppily… they’re squished on one side instead of being more radial. 8/10

Small, cute, lovable. The artist has noticed that the basal pair of leaves in the group are not exactly the same shape as the top leaf, and I could kiss them for it. 10/10

This one is like the Google emoji, but even sloppier. 3/10

Finally…. at long last… PETIOLES! A CHRISTMAS MIRACLE! Shading is simple but gets the job done. 10/10

I’ve never seen a more meh-looking Oxalis in my life. If an emojis had flavor, this one would be untoasted white sponge bread. 4/10

If you’ve gotta go with a cartoony look, this is vastly preferable to Microsoft’s elephant masquerade. 7/10

The leaves are all one unit, growing out of the center stem. What is this, miner’s lettuce? A water lily with chunks missing?? Get your connate-perfoliate garbage out of my thread. 0/10