Context: We’ve followed a bunch of demons through a portal to what we assumed was the Abyss. There’s a Chain Devil putting some Manes to work

Me, OOC: “A Devil? Negotiation time!”

My elf Warlock: “What is a Devil doing in the Abyss?!”

Chain Devil: “I could ask you the same thing”

Warlock: “But I’m not a Devil.”

The DM facepalms. 

Monk, OOC: “ ‘I could ask you the same thing, but that would be incorrect’ ”